Removing a Patron: When Does Force Become Excessive? - Security Guard Course Inc. Skip To Content

Removing a Patron: When Does Force Become Excessive?

Security professionals working in venues like nightclubs, entertainment venues, and hospitals regularly deal with patrons who refuse to leave when directed. These encounters often lead to verbal and even physical confrontations. Alcohol, drugs, and mental illness are often mitigating factors driving a patron’s behaviour. These challenging situations require security guards to make quick decisions and exercise good judgement in order to safely fulfill their duties. This sometimes includes the physical removal of the patron.

 

In Canada, while the law does permit the removal of individuals from private property using reasonable force, excessive force can lead to criminal charges. So, where is the line, and how do we make sure we don’t cross it?

 

An August 2026 incident in Winnipeg raises important questions about what authority security guards in Canada have, the importance of “reasonable force”, and the importance of effective teamwork during physical interventions.

 

This incident also reminds us that having the authority to remove someone does NOT mean by any and all means.

 

The Incident: Three Security Guards Charged

 

At approximately 1 am on August 3, 2026, Winnipeg police responded to a disturbance call at a nightclub in the 400 block of Main Street.

 

According to the police, a 28-year-old patron had been involved in an altercation with security personnel. As a result, the patron required treatment in hospital for his injuries. The patron was later identified as Teddy Allen, a professional basketball player with the Winnipeg Sea Bears.

 

According to news reports, video taken in the club shows Allen being forcefully removed by at least 3 security guards. On August 12, three security guards were arrested and charged with assault causing bodily harm. 

 

As the Winnipeg police stated in their press release, it is important to distinguish between allegations and proven facts. Just because the guards were charged with the crime does not mean they are guilty. Also, the reporting we are using does not provide an account of what happened before, during, or after the physical confrontation.

 

Nevertheless, the fact that the incident occurred offers an opportunity to revisit the role of security when it comes to the physical removal of individuals from private property in Canada.

 

Understanding Removal Authority

 

Security guards in Canada do have the authority to remove unwanted individuals from the private property that they are responsible for protecting. In fact, the authority extends from the property owner themselves to those acting under their direction.

 

For example, a nightclub manager might decide to direct an intoxicated patron to leave the premises due to aggressive behaviour. That information would likely be provided to the patron by security, as they are responsible for enforcing the club’s rules. The challenges arise when the patron refuses to comply.

 

Trespassing Legislation

 

Trespass legislation varies from province to province, but tends to follow the same principle. Property owners are allowed to determine who can enter their property and when, as well as where certain people can and can’t go. They can also decide what activities are allowed and which are not. The legislation allows these rules to be enforceable.

 

In Manitoba, the Trespass Act states that only the police can place someone under arrest for trespassing. In some provinces, such as Ontario’s Trespass to Property Act, security guards can make the arrest.

 

The most important thing about enforcing provincial trespass legislation is that it only authorizes the arrest of a trespassing individual. It does not authorize their physical removal. This authority comes from the Criminal Code of Canada.

 

Criminal Code Section 35: Defense of Property

 

Section 35 is where security guards across Canada get their authority to remove a patron without actually arresting them.

 

In general terms, it allows persons in peaceable possession of property, or are authorized by the person, to take reasonable action to protect that property. Specifically, there must be a belief that someone is/has entered the property, is taking or damaging the property, or refusing to leave when directed. Security often acts as the owner or manager’s representatives.

 

The permissible actions of security under Section 35 include preventing someone from entering, taking, or damaging the property, without legal authority. If they are already on the property, security may remove them using reasonable force. This is where things can get complicated. 

 

While the authority to remove Teddy Allen clearly existed, the manner in which it was applied has been called into question. In any situation where force is an option, there is an expectation that it will only be used after other options prove ineffective. Even then, the force must be appropriate to the objective and circumstances.

 

Reasonable Force: The National Use of Force Framework

 

The National Use of Force Framework provides a conceptual framework for assessing situations and selecting appropriate responses, including the use of force in all of its variations. The framework is used in both public policing and private security. Courts also rely on it when determining whether force used was appropriate to the circumstances in question, as will likely be the case in the Teddy Allen incident.

 

It is important to understand that the framework is not legislation, and carries no independent authority. It is a tool designed to aid in decision-making in real-time, so that the actions taken are in line with existing laws.

 

The framework provides a structure to aid in the assessment and response to a dynamic situation. It recognizes that every situation is unique and fluid. Factors such as the environment, the subject’s behaviour, available options, and resources can vary during an incident. A cooperative subject in a corridor might suddenly become assaultive while walking down the stairs. As circumstances change, so must the guards’ response.

 

The Importance of Communication

 

The majority of confrontations begin with a verbal interaction. Depending on the patron’s emotional state, they may respond in a variety of ways. Feelings of anger, embarrassment, or fear when asked to leave may lead to a defensive response. This could look like verbal non-compliance, argumentative behaviour, or even challenging the guards to fight.

 

The manner in which the guards communicate with the patron influences how the encounter develops. Guards should maintain a calm but directive tone and posture, while providing clear direction to the patron. Explain what you need them to do, followed by the reason. Keep focused on the undesirable behaviour, rather than the patron themselves. An effective strategy is the Refusal Approach:

 

Ask Again: Clearly repeat the request. “I would like you to leave the club.”

Reason: Explain the reason for the request. “When you pushed our server, you violated our violence and harassment policy.”

Benefits: Explain the advantage of cooperation. “If you leave on your own, there won’t be a scene, and you’re welcome to come back another night.”

Options: Explain the other options available to gain compliance. “If you refuse to leave, we will escort you out. If you resist, you will be arrested and turned over to the police to be charged with assault.”

Confirmation: Confirm that the patron understands, and allow them to comply.

Action: Follow through with the appropriate action, depending on the patron’s decision. If they choose to comply, ensure they find their way out. If they refuse, proceed with the escort.

 

Team Intervention…Individual Accountability

 

The Winnipeg incident involved multiple security guards escorting Teddy Allen out of the club. Generally speaking, this is the safest way to respond to a potentially violent situation. However, an effective team approach requires clearly defined roles, with everyone “rowing” in the same direction.

 

Without a coordinated response, things can get chaotic quickly. Training is essential to ensure a coordinated and lawful response.

 

It is important to remember that even during a team response, accountability falls on each guard individually. Each member of the team is responsible for their behaviour. In this incident, three security guards were charged for their actions. Each will be held accountable for their part in the ejection.

 

Lessons and Final Thoughts

 

The incident between Teddy Allen and the three security guards highlights the risks associated with providing security services in a nightclub setting. Training and experience are essential to ensure that these challenging situations are managed both safely, and lawfully. Some important factors to keep in mind include:

 

Know your legal authorities: Be clear in your knowledge of your trespass authorities vs. removal and arrest authorities. In any situation, you may have several options available to you. Each has its pros and cons, as well as do’s and don’ts.

 

Communication before, during AND after: Physical force is the option of last resort. Resistance can often become compliance with the application of strong communication skills.

 

Work as a team: If physical intervention is required, it should be orderly. Predefined roles and strategies maintain safety, effectiveness, and lawfulness. 

 

Continuous assessment: The situation is dynamic, and security’s response must be appropriate to what is happening at the moment. As behavior changes, or risks rise and fall, the response must adjust in real-time. When the threat has ended, or the objective achieved, any applied force must also end.

 

Security guards often find themselves involved in situations that require quick but thoughtful responses. The risk of injury, criminal or civil liability is ever present. It is through good training and experience that guards learn how to navigate situations like the Winnipeg incident. As we can see, the consequences of questionable decisions and actions can be serious. 

 

Excellent training opportunities are abundantly available in many formats. For example, SecurityGuardCourse.ca offers a wide range of self-paced online training programs to prepare you for situations like the one discussed in this post!

 

References

 

Canadian Association of Chiefs of Police. (2000). A national use of force framework. https://www.cacp.ca/_Library/resources/National_Use_of_Force_Framework.pdf⁠

Criminal Code, R.S.C. 1985, c. C-46, ss. 26, 34, 35. https://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/C-46/

Government of Manitoba. (1987). The Trespass Act, C.C.S.M. c. T156. https://web2.gov.mb.ca/laws/statutes/ccsm/t156.php

Government of Ontario. (1990). Trespass to Property Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. T.21. https://www.ontario.ca/laws/statute/90t21.

Patterson, K. (2026, August 13). 3 security guards facing assault charges after Winnipeg Sea Bears’ Teddy Allen injured. CityNews Winnipeg. https://winnipeg.citynews.ca/2026/08/13/teddy-allen-injury-security-guards-assault/

Winnipeg Police Service. (2026, August 13). Assault investigation at licensed premise results in charges: C26-191112. City of Winnipeg. https://www.winnipeg.ca/police/community/news-releases/2026-08-13-assault-investigation-licensed-premise-results-charges-c26-191112